Thursday, January 17, 2013

This is not American Idol, and you are not Simon Cowell

Yesterday, when I went into town to do some shopping, we stopped by McDonalds to grab some lunch, using the McDonald’s card someone gave us for Christmas—it’s a very useful gift and we love it.  We supposedly have a storm coming in and we wanted to make sure we were completely covered in the supply department.  I don’t mind being snowed or iced in, but I’d like to do it with milk, eggs and gasoline for the generator-thank you very much. 

Anyway, there I was at McDonalds eating my chicken sandwich wrapped in lettuce with the television blaring in the background.  Since I don’t have regular TV at home, and only watch internet programs, I found my attention gravitating toward it.  A news program was on and we were watching a “live” police chase in Houston of a suspected bank robber.  As we watched the chase, Robert looks at me and says, “you realize we can’t leave now until we see the ending of this.”  I agreed.  So, there we sat our attention glued to the screen as the guy drove on the interstate, through back streets, his back right tire blown out.  I had to admire his tenacity.  He knew he was being chased by dozens of police cars, yet he just kept going.  I had to wonder, did he really plan this out?  Seriously, who chooses a mini-van as their getaway car?  What drove him to do this?  All these things were knocking around in my skull.  Then he finally pulled over, opened the car door and ran, still being chased by police cars and even one police officer on foot.  After he’d given up, even though he was one man laying face down on the ground surrounded by officers, some police men were still bolting toward the scene as if he may still be a threat.  One of our men in blue tripped on the curb and twisted his ankle.  I heard a collective groan from the people at McDonalds who were all watching this unfold.  “That’s gotta hurt,” I heard someone say. 

Then I thought, “this has got to be the best reality television show yet.”  It wasn’t baked up by some producer for optimum shock value, the reality stars weren’t vetted out with auditions, this was real-time television.  Another thought came across my mind.  This was actually entertainment for us?  Some guy, probably down on his luck robs a bank and we as Americans are sitting around critiquing his car chase and the police who chased him?  We as a society are now in a position to sit around and judge the actions of each other?  I thought about how I play the piano or organ at church and how many times people have commented on my abilities or inabilities, whether I played something well or not, as though I was a contestant on American Idol and they were Simon Cowell.  I have to admit that my first reaction isn’t to quietly take their criticism or critique in a good way and thank them for their opinion; my first thought is to tell them they are welcome to play the piano their damned selves.  This is the society of American Idol.  This is the society where we sit around and judge each others ability to perform and feel completely justified in doing so.  I’m not sure this American Idol society, coupled by reality television we’ve created is positive for humanity or advances our creativity.

Take care, All and remember to keep it real.

No comments:

Post a Comment